This 1840s Captain's Row historic home affectionately known as "Pond View" was meticulously restored to its original grandeur and recently renovated with the luxurious modern amenities. The property has had a series of luminary owners, including a famous composer/conductor, Marvin Hamlisch, a key figure in American Football, Gene Washington, and a ballerina and actress, Patrica H. Hall. This turn-key charmer has four bedrooms, one currently being used as a den/library, three full bathrooms, beautifully landscaped grounds and a gunite plunge pool. Embrace the seasonal western water views of Sag Harbor Cove, majestic views of Otter Pond or enjoy the warmth and ambience of any one of the six fireplaces. As you enter the front door you are greeted by a lovely entry foyer. Turn left to enter the parlor room with fireplace, two exposures and views onto Otter Pond. Head through the pocket doors to the spacious living room with fireplace and wall of glass with French doors that lead out to the deck and yard beyond, creating a seamless connection of indoor/outdoor living. Just off the living room to the right is a cozy den that also overlooks the backyard, and to the left is the kitchen that combines timeless charm and modern amenities, including an original 1840s fireplace/oven and beamed ceiling, along with Viking and Sub-Zero appliances. A full bath with claw tub completes the first floor. Ascend the beautifully restored stairs and railing to three bedrooms, including an expansive primary bedroom, with fireplace, spa like bath with radiant heat floors, two exposure and views over upper Sag Harbor Cove. A second guest suite with a renovated marble bath, private staircase and two exposure, Otter Pond and Sag Cove. A third bedroom with fireplace and two exposures with views of Otter Pond and to the south. The attic is cedar lined for excellent storage. History is beautifully preserved in the lower level that once served as a Village speakeasy and now provides space to relax by the sixth fireplace. The beautiful grounds complete the experience, with lush estate specimen trees and plantings, water feature, heated gunite plunge pool, outdoor shower, as well as separate sitting and dining areas and all surrounded by an 8' Ilex hedge for estate like privacy.